6 Best Natural Toners For All Skin Types

Avatar for TNI Editorial Team
Written by Cambria Glosz
SHARE

This post contains links through which we may earn a small commission should you make a purchase from a brand. This in no way affects our ability to objectively critique the products and brands we review.

dr jennifer hughes

Dr. Jennifer Hughes, MD
Medical Reviewer

While most people are aware that they should be cleansing and moisturizing their face in their skincare routine, many don’t know that there is another step in between those two. 

After washing your face, it’s ideal to use a facial toner, which preps the skin for any serums and moisturizers while also removing any leftover oil or stubborn makeup that your cleanser missed.

Although toners of the past were harsh and tended to dry out the skin, many of today’s face toners are made with natural or organic ingredients that are gentler and more calming.

In this article, check out our list of the six best natural toners, including our top pick, The Organic Skin Co. Set the Tone, plus options for sensitive and acne-prone skin, people on a budget, and those looking for anti-aging toners. 

Natural Face Toner Key Points  Cost
The Organic Skin Co. Set The Tone For all skin types; Contains natural antioxidants and organic aloe vera, honeysuckle, rose oil, and rose flower water; Supercritical CO2 extract increases efficacy; 100% recyclable and sustainable packaging and container; Certified Vegan. $24.99 for 3.4oz($7.35/oz)
Thayers Alcohol-Free Rosewater Facial Toner  Alcohol-free toner good for oily and dry skin types; Certified organic witch hazel and aloe; Improves skin texture by 22%; Farm-to-bottle with handpicked ingredients, 100% cruelty-free, alcohol-free, and dermatologist-tested for safety.  $10.95 for 12oz($0.91/oz)
Paula’s Choice Skin Recovery Contains vitamin E, borage seed oil, evening primrose, and hyaluronic acid for sensitive and dry skin; Paraben- and fragrance-free; 100% cruelty-free; Good for people with rosacea or eczema. $23 for 6.4oz($3.41/oz)
La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Solution Contains salicylic acid and glycolic acid to fight acne and breakouts; Targets clogged pores; Affordable; Paraben-free; Not organic. $16.99 for 6.76oz($2.51/oz)
Mario Badescu Aloe Vera Toner Key ingredient is aloe vera; Good for dry or flaky skin; Alcohol-free and cruelty-free; Affordable; Not organic. $15 for 8oz($1.88/oz)
TULA Antioxidant Water Purifying Face Mist Contains hyaluronic acid, witch hazel, wild mint, green tea, and wild butterfly ginger as anti-aging agents; Contains cucumber water and holy basil to soothe and calm irritated skin; Blend of six prebiotics and probiotics to nourish skin microbiome; Fights skin damage from aging, pollution, and blue light; Facial mist is easier to use  $36 for 3.71oz($10.26/oz)

Overall Best Natural Face Toner: The Organic Skin Co. Set the Tone

the organic skin co. set the tone mist toner
  • Pros
  • Organic ingredients
  • Great for all skin types 
  • Supercritical CO2 extraction increases efficacy
  • Sustainable packaging
  • Cons
  • Premium price
  • Smaller bottle

Best for: People with all skin types looking for a premium, natural, organic face toner; those looking to support anti-aging.

Our top toner pick is The Organic Skin Co. Set the Tone, a natural and organic toner with aloe vera, rose water, honeysuckle, and rose oil. 

These ingredients are anti-aging, calming, and nutrient-rich, ensuring that your skin gets the hydration and nourishment it needs after cleansing. 

One thing that makes The Organic Skin Co. stand out is their use of “supercritical CO2 extraction,” an innovative process that not only increases the effectiveness of the ingredient but is also a cleaner method. 

Rather than relying on chemical or alcohol solvents to extract the active compounds, CO2 extraction uses compressed CO2 gas at a low temperature to “wash through” a plant or herb.

This process allows for a greater yield and maximum extraction of the active compounds, longer shelf life, and reduced environmental impact. 

Plus, The Organic Skin Co. Set the Tone can also be used as a natural perfume, making this a two-in-one purchase. 

Best Value Facial Toner: Thayers Alcohol-Free Rosewater Facial Toner 

thayers alcohol-free rosewater facial toner
  • Pros
  • Affordable and larger size
  • Alcohol-free toner good for oily and dry skin types
  • Certified organic witch hazel and aloe
  • Improves skin texture by 22%
  • Cons
  • Not a mist/spray (have to use with cotton pads)

Best for: People on a budget looking for an alcohol-free toner made with organic ingredients. 

For those looking for natural face toners at a great value, Thayers Alcohol-Free Rosewater Facial Toner is your best bet.

With a 12oz bottle filled with 98% organic and natural ingredients—including organic witch hazel grown and harvested on a family farm in Connecticut and organic aloe vera—this natural rosewater toner does not skimp on quality. 

Other ingredients in Thayers toner include distilled rose petals, which create vitamin C-rich rosewater that helps to restore dehydrated skin, promote collagen production, and fade blemishes or scars. 

Witch hazel is another key ingredient in this formula, which tightens pores, controls oil production, and fights free radicals in the skin. 

According to Thayers, this toner helps to improve skin texture by 22% and can start working within one day. 

Plus, Thayers Alcohol-Free Rosewater Facial Toner is farm-to-bottle with handpicked ingredients, 100% cruelty-free, alcohol-free, and dermatologist-tested for safety. 

Best Natural Toner for Sensitive Skin: Paula’s Choice Skin Recovery

paula's choice skin recovery enriched calming toner
  • Pros
  • Contains vitamin E, borage seed oil, evening primrose, and hyaluronic acid for sensitive and dry skin
  • Paraben- and fragrance-free
  • 100% cruelty-free 
  • Cons
  • Not a mist/spray (have to use with cotton pads)

Best for: People with sensitive, extra-dry, rosacea-prone, or eczema-prone skin. 

If you have sensitive or extra-dry skin, Paula’s Choice Skin Recovery is the toner choice for you.

With vitamins C, E, and B3, borage seed oil, evening primrose, and hyaluronic acid, this formula is designed for people who haven’t been able to use toners due to their often-drying nature. 

Paula’s Choice toner has a uniquely creamy texture (more like a lighter moisturizer) instead of a mist or clear liquid, which helps to restore lost lipids (natural fats in skin tissue) and replenish skin after cleansing. 

This toner is also great for people with rosacea or eczema, as it’s highly calming and provides non-fragrant plant oils that are rich in protective antioxidants and reduce dry, flaky skin.   

Best Natural Toner for Acne-Prone or Oily Skin: La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Solution

la roche-posay effaclar clarifying solution
  • Pros
  • Contains salicylic acid and glycolic acid to fight acne and breakouts
  • Targets clogged pores
  • Affordable
  • Paraben-free
  • Cons
  • No organic ingredients 

Best for: People prone to breakouts and acne; those wanting to minimize pores. 

If you are prone to acne and clogged pores, La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Solution is an excellent toner to help fight breakouts. 

Unlike many other skin toners, this one contains two active acne-fighting ingredients: salicylic acid and glycolic acid, a type of AHA (alpha-hydroxy acid) that is used as a chemical exfoliant in the skin to remove debris from pores. 

This exfoliating acne toner also helps to improve skin tone by removing excess dirt, dead skin cells, or other debris from the skin to maintain a smooth texture. 

However, while La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Solution is on the more affordable side, there are no organic ingredients in this toner. 

Best Natural Face Toner for Dry Skin: Mario Badescu Aloe Vera Toner

mario badescu aloe vera toner
  • Pros
  • Good for dry or flaky skin
  • Alcohol-free and cruelty-free
  • Affordable 
  • Cons
  • Not organic

Best for: People with dry or flaky skin; people with sensitive skin. 

Although the symptoms are often overlapping and many people can have both, dry skin and sensitive skin are not always the same.

For example, dry skin can be flaky and rough in texture, while sensitive skin often stings, burns, or becomes red after using certain products. 

This Mario Badescu Aloe Vera Toner is an excellent option for people with dry skin, as it’s loaded with highly soothing and nourishing aloe vera. 

It’s also alcohol-free, which is a must-have for people with dry skin, as alcohol can further dry out the skin. 

However, one downside is that you won’t find any organic ingredients here. 

Best Anti-Aging Face Toner: TULA Antioxidant Water Purifying Face Mist

tula antioxidant water purifying toner face mist
  • Pros
  • Contains hyaluronic acid, witch hazel, wild mint, green tea, and wild butterfly ginger as anti-aging agents 
  • Cucumber water and holy basil soothe and calm irritated skin
  • Blend of six prebiotics and probiotics nourish the skin microbiome
  • Fights skin damage from aging, pollution, and blue light
  • Facial mist is easier to use
  • Cons
  • Expensive
  • Not organic

Best for: People looking for a premium, natural facial toner with many supporting ingredients for anti-aging; those looking to protect their skin from damage from blue light or pollution. 

With over a dozen beneficial ingredients, TULA Antioxidant Water Purifying Face Mist is our top pick for a natural toner to support anti-aging. 

This TULA toner contains:

  • Hyaluronic acid, witch hazel, and wild mint leaf to purify and hydrate the skin
  • Green tea and wild butterfly ginger as antioxidants that defend against skin aging and damage from pollution and blue light
  • Six prebiotics and probiotics to nourish the skin microbiome 
  • Cucumber water and holy basil as a refreshing touch to soothe and calm irritated or red skin

Although this toner is priced at a premium, you won’t find this impressive ingredient lineup in any other organic toner. 

FAQs about Natural Toners 

What Makes a Good Natural Toner?

Natural toners are made without alcohol, preservatives, or other synthetic ingredients, and typically contain ingredients like cucumber, rose water, aloe vera, or witch hazel. 

Is Apple Cider Vinegar a Good Face Toner?

Apple cider vinegar (ACV) can be used as a DIY toner. However, be sure not to use straight ACV on your face, as it needs to be diluted. 

Make your own DIY toner by combining 2 Tbsp ACV with 8oz of plain water, then add it to a spray/mister bottle or soak a cotton pad with it to use as a toner. 

If you have dry skin, consider reducing the ACV amount to 1 Tbsp, as it can be drying.

What Are the Key Ingredients for Toners?

Good toners combine ingredients that are more astringent and can remove impurities from the skin (like witch hazel) with nourishing and hydrating ingredients, like aloe vera or rose water.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *